How I try out new materials

I often see people at art material trade shows or art supply stores, trying out pencils, pens, paints or papers by making a few quick strokes.  In ten seconds, they’ve already decided whether they like it or not and will ever buy it.  They put it down and walk away. This is unfortunate.  Think of how many things you hated or were awful at on your very first attempt or usage:  climbing a tree, driving a car, wearing a bra, drinking beer, speaking in front of a group, ice skating, using a new phone.  In each case, there is nothing inherently wrong with the object or activity, it’s only that one quick try isn’t enough to understand it or have any skill with it.  One needs to invest a little more time with it, and then it’s fine.  It might even be better than fine, it might be terrific!

Many art supply manufacturers know of this short-attention-span problem and give out free samples for folks to take home and try on a small project.  A small sheet of paper, or a pencil, for example.  But that doesn’t seem to help; many artists I know have drawers or boxes full of free samples they’ve never used but can’t bring themselves to donate.

I have a few free samples laying around, too.  But if something comes recommended, such as a particular brand of colored pencils or a particular type of paper, I don’t simply do a quickie scribble.  I launch into a full-scale project with it.  By the end of the project, I’ve spent several hours learning how that material behaves under the full range of my expectations, and I either have a new finished artwork to add to my body of work, or a binned failure.  The latter is pretty rare, though, because I can generally augment the process with materials I do already like and it turns out fine anyway.

Two recent cases illustrate my point.

Case #1: Pencils

Tree of Stories, 15"x20", colored pencil on Stonehenge paper

Tree of Stories, 15″ x 20″, colored pencil on Stonehenge paper

Tree of Stories was my first time using Faber-Castell Polychromos colored pencils.  It’s 15″ x 20″, so I knew I was in for several weeks of familiarization.

The first few strokes I put on my Stonehenge paper, I thought “Uh-oh, this isn’t going to work at all.  I’ve made an expensive mistake buying the whole 120 set.”  They are oil-based so are much more powdery than waxy Prismacolor Premiers or Caran d’Ache Luminance.  Because of that, I could lightly run my finger across the surface of the paper and quite a bit of pigment lifted right off.  Horrors!  But then I thought, “Well, maybe I can use that powderiness to my advantage–it probably will fill the tooth of the paper easier.”  And it did.  I was careful to keep a paper shield under my drawing hand at all times and never scoot it to move it.

Then after a day or two I noticed that it seemed the darker colors had faded and I had to re-apply them to enforce their intensity.  It wasn’t my imagination.  From talking to other artists I learned that Stonehenge paper seems to absorb something in the Polychromos.  That was easy to fix–I added a bit of Prismacolor on top of those areas.  By the time I finished a few weeks later, I knew how to use Polychromos pencils to do what I want, admired their range of browns and greens, and had a drawing that was good enough for acceptance into the 2014 CPSA International Exhibition.

If I had stopped after those first few strokes, Tree of Stories would still have happened with other pencils, but I would be telling people, very mistakenly, that these great Polychromos pencils are awful.

Case #2: Paper

Mutual Support, 14"x21", graphite on Canson 88 paper

Mutual Support, 14″ x 21″, graphite on Canson 88 paper

Mutual Support, 14″ x 21″, was my first time using Arches 88 paper.  I had been looking for some good paper for graphite, to achieve darks without a lot of shininess.  Stonehenge paper works great for colored pencil but isn’t quite what I wanted for graphite.  Gil McMillon, the owner of Accent Arts in Palo Alto, suggested another printmaking paper, Arches 88.  It’s 100% cotton like Stonehenge but has almost a plate surface.  I was skeptical–how could such a smooth surface work for graphite?  I bought a single 22″x30″ sheet for about $8.50–quite a bit more than a sheet of Stonehenge costs.  The first few strokes I took on it seemed to confirm my fear–there was virtually no tooth at all, so the graphite went on very smoothly.  I thought “Oh no, the pencil is going to skate right off the surface and the whole drawing will end up light gray. I just wasted $8.50 on this big sheet I can’t use for anything else.”  But I kept going, and within an hour I was sold on it.  The fact that it’s 100% cotton makes it hold graphite despite its plate surface. It’s easy to achieve smooth shading and very dark darks since there is virtually no tooth to fill.  I used only a 4B pencil for the entire drawing and am very pleased with how it turned out.  I returned to Accent Arts yesterday to buy two more sheets!

To summarize, it takes more than a few strokes to decide if an art material is right for your way of working; you won’t really know before you invest a few hours with it.  Be brave, launch into a full-fledged piece with the same determination you give to your usual work.

9 thoughts on “How I try out new materials

  1. I do something similar when I’m sewing, or baking (back when I could), or when I’m making costumes for my kids. Esp. costumes. Every year I use a new medium. And I just go right at it, tweaking and compensating and learning as I go along. (For one thing, it’s part of the fun!) I’m with you–a short little trial isn’t enough to really learn anything. And, I can’t bring myself to spend that much time and attention on sheer practice. I’d rather have a completed-but-not-great actual thing as my practice than have a few scattered things that are clearly just practice.

  2. A great post Denise! You are absolutely right, a quick test of any materials can easily give a skewed response. I saw your pencil drawing earlier today and loved it – beautiful work (both pieces)! I shall look forward to following you.

  3. I found your blogs to be very informative and interesting. Not really knowing what using different types of paper to try to achieve my goals, I feel I can test the ones you’ve used to get the results desired. I really love your swatch approach for keeping up with the proper colors.

    Thank you for all of your useful information.

  4. Great article. Thank-you for sharing your knowledge. I’m always looking for new papers to experiment with. I’ve googled this paper ‘canson88’ but am not sure that I’m coming up with the correct paper. They call it arches 88 silkscreen paper made by Carson ?? Do you know where I could buy this paper online?

    • Kathy, thank you for catching my error! It is indeed Arches 88 paper, and no it is not made by Canson as I indicated, it’s made by Arches. I’ve corrected my posting. I think Blick carries it online.

  5. Thanks for sharing your experience and knowledge, I found your posts helpful and interesting. I am planning to draw a landscape using Faber-Castell Polychrome colored-pencils. I have a pack of Strathmore paper (drawing paper, 70 lb). I tried it once and it was decent, just It is a little bit thin. I am not sure this paper will work for landscape. Do you know if using Stonehenge makes a big difference? I also found Stonehenge(90lb) has two options (1)Individual sheets and (2) the ones that sold in pads. I don’t know which one is working better for landscape.
    Thanks again for the information.

    • Hi Roj, thanks for your feedback!

      I agree, the Strathmore 400 Colored Pencil paper seems rather thin. There is now “Stonehenge Lightweight” paper available in pads, which is thinner and cheaper than regular Stonehenge and competes directly with that Strathmore paper. I still prefer the “regular” Stonehenge paper in either pads or individual sheets. Sheets are better when you need to work in a non-standard size and/or want to save money. With the pads you pay more for the pre-cut sizing and packaging. Even when I make a drawing that’s a standard size, I leave a 1/2″ margin all around to make matting and framing easier.

      When choosing paper, your subject matter (landscape) is less important than how heavy-handed you are with your pencils. If you tend to use significant pressure and a lot of layers, you need paper that can stand up to the abuse without getting wavy or breaking down. Regular Stonehenge is good for that! Some other papers are, too, such as Fabriano Artistico 140 lb. hot-pressed watercolor paper (but it’s even more expensive than Stonehenge).

      Note that most papers have a front and back side, and the back is slightly smoother than the front. You may have to hold it to a strong light at a sharp angle to tell which is which, but it’s worth doing because that subtle difference may show up in your drawing. Some people prefer the front side, some people prefer the back.

      Hope that helps!

      • Thanks for detailed and clear explanation. I very much appreciate your help.
        Feel great for finding your website and blog 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s